Source: at://did:plc:v2j2g5pdghrwazhbw6gvxtdp/app.bsky.feed.post/3lq7gxnv75f2m
People came to their senses and now I'm back.
Thanks everyone!
Maybe my husband ( @merrystarchild.bsky.social ) and I are not as 'unhinged' as some might want others to believe. This could be an example of the 'bandwagon' effect. (#10)
bywordofmaus.com/blog-1/on-ma…
2025-05-28 05:12:45.650 / 3lq7gxnv75f2m
I've realized that this article is suffering from a major issue: it doesn't have a way to 'bookmark' using an HTML anchor (the '#part' of the URI/URL) each manipulation. I'm working to fix that, but in the mean time, here is a set of threads of each one that can be quote-posted at will.
2025-05-28 19:58:22.667 / 3lqayhbcbdf2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.inWhat Is It, And How Can You Identify It?
Just like "boundaries", the word "manipulation" is liberally used in online spaces, …
2025-05-28 20:03:54.637 / 3lqayr5v6rv2w
particularly those that are already contaminated by the dime-store counterpart of healthy mental health practices—the Mental Wellness Influencer sphere and all of its dendritic manifestations.
2025-05-28 20:03:54.638 / 3lqayr6zwkv2w
It has become an incantation to use against others that, in current discourse, requires little or no backing explanation. In fact, when pressed, many who use the word seem to be incapable of explaining why something is manipulative, or even what manipulation actually is by definition.
2025-05-28 20:03:54.639 / 3lqayr6zwkw2w
This highlights the very precarious position in which the current state of discourse and critical thinking finds itself.
2025-05-28 20:03:54.640 / 3lqayr6zyjg2w
The Nature Of Manipulation
bywordofmaus.com/blog-1/on-ma…
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in
The base objective reality is that all communication is manipulation at its core.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.832 / 3lqb2rh5kjo2w
People communicate for a myriad of reasons to accomplish a vast number of goals in an endless variety of ways. To articulate for the purpose of achieving something, particularly if it is to persuade, is to manipulate. All human beings are capable of manipulative behavior.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.833 / 3lqb2rijqlo2w
When a baby cries, it is a manipulation of the parent to care for them.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.834 / 3lqb2rijqlp2w
As children, we are often manipulative as we discover our impact on our environment and seek to influence others around us while being primarily helpless. Babies as young as 15 months old already know their parents will pick them up if they cry.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.835 / 3lqb2rijqlq2w
In a 2018 article published in Psychology & Clinical Psychiatry, Olga V Kozachek (Associate Professor of Pedagogy, Early Childhood Education, Volgograd State Pedagogical University, Russia) …
2025-05-28 20:39:51.836 / 3lqb2rijqlr2w
recounts a 2010 encounter in which professionals identified 160 common manipulative tactics in preschool-aged children.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.837 / 3lqb2rijrkz2w
('The age and the psychological conditions of the manipulative behavior of preschool children,' referencing 'Kozachek OV. Psychological manipulation of pre-school age children in the family and preschool. …
2025-05-28 20:39:51.838 / 3lqb2rijrl22w
Pre-school education in the XXI century: materials Intern. Scientific and practical. Volgograd; 2010:170−173.’ )
2025-05-28 20:39:51.839 / 3lqb2rijrl32w
I quote, at times editing for linguistic clarity (English not being Dr. Kozachek's native language), "during … 2009-2018 … professionals directly related to the education of preschool children" were invited "to discuss the current state of the problem of children's manipulations."
2025-05-28 20:39:51.840 / 3lqb2rijrl42w
The study "involved 188 teachers, music educators, and instructors in physical education in preschools across Volgograd and the surrounding region" in Russia.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.841 / 3lqb2rijrl52w
"According to their reflections and examples from personal experience, teachers could list more than 160 tricks children use" in daily interactions. Among the most popular methods were the assertions of a contagion by which to judge others,
2025-05-28 20:39:51.842 / 3lqb2rijrl62w
"lies, hysteria, using other people's weaknesses, flattery, insincere promises, references to their own, sometimes feigned, weaknesses, and manipulations of affection."
2025-05-28 20:39:51.843 / 3lqb2rijrl72w
Common themes framing these strategies were "the use of someone else's authority, a set up pitting people against each other, and deliberately creating a sense of [imposed or artificial] guilt."
2025-05-28 20:39:51.844 / 3lqb2rijskh2w
These are academically published descriptions from professional educators of observed preschool dynamics in Volgograd, Russia, from 2009 to 2018.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.845 / 3lqb2rijski2w
As we grow and our understanding of the world and its social dynamics becomes more sophisticated, we will ideally adapt to other, less coercive strategies. That being said, an attempt to move a third party will always remain the core of social interaction:
2025-05-28 20:39:51.846 / 3lqb2rijskj2w
we share common interests in the hopes of forming meaningful bonds; we communicate causes to move others to join our fight; we express our needs and wants in the hope that they will be met, just as others hope that theirs will be met by disclosing them to us.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.847 / 3lqb2rijskk2w
This is all well and good, necessary even. However, that abstract and scientific linguistic perspective might obscure what I will be presenting: when this manipulation is coercive via an ulterior motivation and its reliance on dishonest representations of reality.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.848 / 3lqb2rijskl2w
To differentiate healthy, appropriate interactions from these types of manipulation, we can identify them as persuasion.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.849 / 3lqb2rijtjt2w
It is the manipulation, not persuasion, to which I and countless mental health influencers, podcasters, and YouTubers refer to when discussing manipulation, though you will notice that very few of them touch upon the subject beyond
2025-05-28 20:39:51.850 / 3lqb2rijtju2w
saying 'this person is manipulative' or 'their actions are manipulative' without explicitly saying why this is so.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.851 / 3lqb2rijtjv2w
At its most basic definition, manipulation is influencing a third party to do something they might not want to do of their own volition, usually for the benefit of the manipulator. Manipulation often occurs through indirect and subtle methods but can also be self-evident and forceful.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.852 / 3lqb2rijtjw2w
The salient difference between persuasion and manipulation is that the mechanics of persuasion are not covert or coercive. Persuasion allows individuals the freedom to accept or reject our influence.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.853 / 3lqb2rijtjx2w
It often consists of an argument directly appealing to the individual's beliefs, religion, motivations, reason, or behavior without subterfuge.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.854 / 3lqb2rijtjy2w
Conversely, manipulation seeks to target an emotional core, an irreplaceable value, or seek to obscure reality to indirectly bypass our critical thinking and informed judgment or place us in extremely unfair situations.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.855 / 3lqb2rijtjz2w
Manipulation is always coercive.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.856 / 3lqb2rijtk22w
In The Narcissist's Playbook, psychotherapist Dana Morningstar states that in terms of close relationships: "Manipulation is a slow and steady imbalance of power.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.857 / 3lqb2rijtk32w
This imbalance is created when one person leverages the emotions of fear, obligation, or guilt against another with the ultimate goal of getting their way."
2025-05-28 20:39:51.858 / 3lqb2rijujd2w
In the realm of social interactions, George K. Simon, author of In Sheep's Clothing: Understanding and Dealing with Manipulative People, identifies five common vulnerabilities that are targeted by manipulative tactics in interpersonal relationships:
2025-05-28 20:39:51.859 / 3lqb2rijuje2w
Naïveté or immaturity: Someone's lack of experience or unwillingness to believe people can be deceitful and manipulative.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.860 / 3lqb2rijujf2w
Over-conscientiousness: Someone's tendency to be overly self-critical, excessively willing to give others the benefit of the doubt, and habitually quick to shoulder blame.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.861 / 3lqb2rijujg2w
Low self-esteem: Individuals who grapple with self-doubt, a lack of confidence, and low assertiveness are described as having low self-esteem. They frequently question their right to pursue their legitimate desires and needs.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.862 / 3lqb2rijujh2w
This often supervenes a pathological eagerness to yield when confronted by an aggressive personality.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.863 / 3lqb2rijuji2w
Over-intellectualization: People who believe that others are hurtful only when there's a legitimate or understandable reason will tend to be convinced that a simple reveal of the motivations and understanding them will create lasting change.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.864 / 3lqb2rijujj2w
This intellectual exercise ignores the reality that one can never truly know someone's motivations. People are often irrational, and cause and effect may not apply.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.865 / 3lqb2rijujk2w
Emotional dependency: Those with submissive or dependent personalities are more vulnerable to manipulation and exploitation, as their emotional reliance on others leaves them wide open. They lack a self-defined and controlled regulatory center and rely on someone else to provide stability.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.866 / 3lqb2rijvis2w
Unfortunately, that need doesn't automatically translate into a trustworthy caretaker.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.867 / 3lqb2rijvit2w
A manipulator "attempts to control or exploits others because this is how they navigate life," writes Morningstar, and to accomplish this, the individual "continually creates chaos." She makes a point to observe that manipulators may do so consciously or unconsciously,
2025-05-28 20:39:51.868 / 3lqb2rijviu2w
and the root of their anti-social behavior may be discovered deep in childhood trauma or in an open emotional wound.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.869 / 3lqb2rijviv2w
There's a likely chance that the person being manipulated will never truly know the origin of the manipulator's behavior, as manipulators often misrepresent the reasons behind their course of action.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.870 / 3lqb2rijviw2w
Malignant narcissists, as well as emotionally immature persons, often resort to manipulative tactics, but it is crucial to steer clear of the generalization that every manipulative individual is a malignant narcissist.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.871 / 3lqb2rijvix2w
Even if the same caution and decoupling techniques must be used to break away from their manipulative behavior, they don't directly correlate to the existence of a non-diagnostic subtype only mentioned in alternative models of personality disorders.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.872 / 3lqb2rijviy2w
To assume as much is to employ stereotypes, which only reduce the real complexities of humans to unrealistic mechanical systems. These eliminate essential contexts in the process and only afford the user a false sense of safety with knowledge that seems complete due to its superficial objectivity.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.873 / 3lqb2rijviz2w
Such blindspots only become further exploited by truly clever manipulators who will foster a righteous sense of us versus them, branding those individuals as justifiable targets to their communities.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.874 / 3lqb2rijvj22w
According to Morningstar, manipulators often coercively influence others for the following reasons: to advance an agenda, to get and maintain power over others, to feel in control, and to feed their egos. Each of these reasons comes with carry-on psychological patterns of thought and behavior:
2025-05-28 20:39:51.875 / 3lqb2rijwic2w
To advance an agenda: The manipulator wants a particular outcome, such as accepting an ordinarily taboo behavior or eliminating a perceived threat. To do so, manipulators often disguise their motives to get their way.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.876 / 3lqb2rijwid2w
They usually present a front of being benevolent, interested in others, honest, and caring for the sole purpose of earning others' confidence and trust in their cause.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.877 / 3lqb2rijwie2w
Their actions will center a concern for their target or the target's interests, which may be external to the situation, making them a valuable ally in achieving the greater good.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.878 / 3lqb2rijwif2w
To get and maintain power over others: Manipulators operate under a zero-sum fallacy, where any empowered individual translates to the manipulator's power being diminished.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.879 / 3lqb2rijwig2w
Self-assertiveness and attempts to exercise your agency are perceived as taking power away from the manipulator, tagging you as an enemy who needs to be retaliated against and brought back under control.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.880 / 3lqb2rijwih2w
To feel in control: Due to an unsteady sense of self or chronic paranoia, manipulators constantly need to exert control over their emotions—and everyone else's.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.881 / 3lqb2rijwii2w
What better way to maintain safety and reduce the ever-present fearful paranoia of someone figuring it all out than to have no one feel like something's wrong?
2025-05-28 20:39:51.882 / 3lqb2rijwij2w
They have an intense, pathological need to always be right, and their egos become deeply unsettled and go into a tailspin when they are proven wrong, faced with disagreement, or challenged.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.883 / 3lqb2rijwik2w
To feed their egos: Manipulators are deeply insecure, though they may not always see themselves this way. Their dishonesty creates a social environment that is extremely fragile, enslaving them to the maintenance of others' false beliefs.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.884 / 3lqb2rijwil2w
This creates a need to feel superior as a form of self-soothing comfort or validation. To be as exceptional as they feel, they undermine the sanity of others and spread chaos, sometimes even boasting about their ability to lay traps for people and maneuver them toward self-indulgent outcomes.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.885 / 3lqb2rijxht2w
To satisfy this ideal self, which can never be satiated because it's false, they work to ensure that they are desired, adored, acclaimed, or, failing that, feared.
2025-05-28 20:39:51.886 / 3lqb2rijxhu2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in1. Denial
These are outright denials of wrongdoing. It usually remains unaccompanied by supporting facts or observations; if they are present, they are indirect, vague, distracting, or loosely connected.
2025-05-28 20:45:42.714 / 3lqb33vrnqu2w
"That never happened! You're making things up. They're lying."
2025-05-28 20:45:42.715 / 3lqb33x32x42w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in2. Shifting Blame
The person at fault deflects blame onto the other party, portraying them as guilty or responsible for the perpetrator's actions. This is the R, for reversal, in the DARVO acronym.
2025-05-28 20:46:34.971 / 3lqb35hmfy42w
"You really shouldn’t have said anything to provoke me. This could’ve all been avoided if you just stayed quiet."
2025-05-28 20:46:34.972 / 3lqb35itrqm2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in3. Isolation
Manipulation is most effective when the target lacks someone nearby who can ground them or alert them that what they're experiencing is, in fact, problematic.
2025-05-28 20:47:53.523 / 3lqb37sjmw42w
The manipulator will seek to isolate the target from family, close friends, etc, making themselves the center of their world.
"Your friends just don't understand you the way I do. Maybe you should spend less time with them. They don't seem to be a good influence, and isn't your life better now?"
2025-05-28 20:47:53.524 / 3lqb37u6lau2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in4. Vilification
This tactic effectively puts the victim on the defensive while masking the manipulator's aggressive intent. When the victim defends themselves or their position, the manipulator counters by falsely accusing them …
2025-05-28 20:50:22.146 / 3lqb3eab7lm2w
… of being the abuser. This is the last whole element of DARVO: Reverse Victim and Offender.
"It’s amazing how you can twist every little thing I do into something negative. Maybe you should look at your own behavior before pointing fingers."
2025-05-28 20:50:22.147 / 3lqb3ebkdym2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in5. Threats of Self-Harm
The manipulator leverages their well-being as a weapon, making others feel responsible for their safety or emotional stability. This tactic can create a powerful sense of urgency and emotional turmoil, …
2025-05-28 20:52:04.849 / 3lqb3hc7ihm2w
… often forcing the target to comply with the manipulator's demands to avoid perceived harm or responsibility for the outcome.
"If you break up with me, I don't think I'll be able to go on."
"If you keep talking about me, it'll make me start cutting again."
2025-05-28 20:52:04.850 / 3lqb3hdgjie2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in6. Passive Aggression
Aggression is forcing a situation to go your way. Passive aggression is trying to get things to go your way without looking like you're doing anything, hence it's passivity.
2025-05-28 20:53:12.868 / 3lqb3jd3ac42w
The most straightforward way to do this is to imply something without explicitly stating it. This behavior forces the target to be constantly vigilant, guessing, and trying to anticipate or adapt to the manipulator's moods and responses.
2025-05-28 20:53:12.869 / 3lqb3jedkde2w
It's most apparent when the manipulator says things they clearly don't mean to emphasize what's not being said.
2025-05-28 20:53:12.870 / 3lqb3jedlcm2w
But what's the payoff? Because the manipulator never explicitly says what remains unsaid, they more easily shirk responsibility for their implicit demands or the act of coercion.
2025-05-28 20:53:12.871 / 3lqb3jedlcn2w
"Don't worry about me. I'll just handle everything on my own, like always. There's no real need to inconvenience yourself."
2025-05-28 20:53:12.872 / 3lqb3jedlco2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in7. Guilt-Tripping
This one's relatively straightforward and easily recognizable, but that quality doesn't make it any easier to defend yourself against it. Very few of us want anyone to significantly suffer, …
2025-05-28 20:55:10.209 / 3lqb3msya3o2w
… and if we think we might be the cause, we'll do whatever we can to stop it. However, such a strong reaction is ripe for abuse, and manipulators will often use guilt to control and influence others.
2025-05-28 20:55:10.210 / 3lqb3mu6yd62w
"All the girls have been preparing for months and are so excited to meet you, but you can say no if you want; it's all up to you. I just know everyone will be really disappointed if you don't come."
2025-05-28 20:55:10.211 / 3lqb3mu6yd72w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in8. Shaming
No one likes being ashamed, particularly if it's something they weren't ashamed of before, and it catches them off guard. There's always the fear of being shunned, ostracized, not measuring up, …
2025-05-28 20:56:42.841 / 3lqb3pld4zp2w
… or suffering other destructive consequences. It comes naturally to many of us to do whatever we can to decrease the negative focus on us.
2025-05-28 20:56:42.842 / 3lqb3pna56h2w
In line with this, manipulators use put-downs to create fear, self-doubt, and a sense of unworthiness, shaming victims into submission and fostering feelings of inadequacy.
2025-05-28 20:56:42.843 / 3lqb3pna65p2w
“If you keep acting this way, I’m honestly not sure how anyone could take you seriously. People are already starting to wonder what’s wrong with you.”
2025-05-28 20:56:42.844 / 3lqb3pna65q2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in9. Lying, By Commission or Omission
These are subtle deceptions made by manufacturing a narrative or omitting a substantial portion of the truth.
2025-05-28 20:58:23.274 / 3lqb3sl444y2w
Claiming, for example, that someone gave you a sarcastic and harsh reply to something you said while omitting an entire section of the conversation that would reveal the larger context: the remark resulted from prolonged provocation.
2025-05-28 20:58:23.275 / 3lqb3smcgoy2w
Because it's sarcastic and appears malevolent when lacking this context, its exclusive purpose is to unfairly paint the subject negatively.
2025-05-28 20:58:23.276 / 3lqb3smchoa2w
This performance omits parts of the evidence that makes the manipulator look bad. When the manipulator doesn't reference the original facts, and others are discouraged from finding them out, this technique will go unnoticed and lie outside immediate awareness, making it highly effective.
2025-05-28 20:58:23.277 / 3lqb3smchob2w
No one thinks something might be wrong if they aren't aware of why [they should].
2025-05-28 20:58:23.278 / 3lqb3smcinj2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in10. Bandwagon Effect or Threatened Ostracism
The manipulator pressures the victim into compliance by suggesting, truthfully or not, that many others have already done something or think in a particular manner.
2025-05-28 20:59:22.404 / 3lqb3udilcb2w
Thus, the victim should too.
2025-05-28 20:59:22.405 / 3lqb3uetmar2w
This doesn't always manifest negatively to the target, as it may be a way to simulate acceptance in the victim's mind of what they've always been too afraid to do. The danger lies in the artificiality of that acceptance because reality will fail to meet inaccurate expectations.
2025-05-28 20:59:22.406 / 3lqb3uetmas2w
"Everybody I've talked to agrees with me, it's really okay. You're the only one who has an issue with it, so you must be the one who's wrong. We all want to do it."
2025-05-28 20:59:22.407 / 3lqb3uetmat2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in11. Playing The Victim
The manipulator pretends to be a victim of circumstances or someone else's actions to evoke pity, sympathy, or compassion to manipulate others into giving them what they want …
2025-05-28 21:00:47.905 / 3lqb3wuzvdt2w
… or to excuse otherwise unacceptable behavior. The most significant sign that it's a play is that the manipulator is only a victim per their invention; it usually isn't readily noticeable until they announce a novel framing of such.
2025-05-28 21:00:47.906 / 3lqb3wwbqqd2w
Compassionate and conscientious individuals who struggle to see others suffer are especially vulnerable to this tactic, making it an effective tool for gaining support and cooperation.
2025-05-28 21:00:47.907 / 3lqb3wwbrpl2w
Partner A: "I've been struggling, and I really needed you to be there for me."
2025-05-28 21:00:47.908 / 3lqb3wwbsot2w
Partner B: "You're always making everything about you. I've got so much on my plate, and now you're acting like I'm a bad partner? Maybe if I didn't have to deal with your constant complaints, I could actually focus on what's important."
2025-05-28 21:00:47.909 / 3lqb3wwbsou2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in12. Spinning or Rationalization
A rationalization is an explanation manipulators give to justify their inappropriate behavior. It's meant to evoke sympathy, sound reasonable, or otherwise appeal to others' biases.
2025-05-28 21:02:39.045 / 3lqb426zljm2w
The least sophisticated and most frequent form is one of excuse. Something about them, or the circumstances, created a lack of choice.
2025-05-28 21:02:39.046 / 3lqb42aaine2w
One recent variation in some circles is an invocation of trauma responses or triggers, effectively displacing the responsibility for actions towards a psychological mechanism rather than the individual's own willful choices.
2025-05-28 21:02:39.047 / 3lqb42aainf2w
However, more sophisticated forms will repackage the victim's objections into broader, more acceptable language. This strips the target of legitimate considerations involving their comfort or interests.
2025-05-28 21:02:39.048 / 3lqb42aajmn2w
“Look, I know I lashed out, but I’ve been under so much stress lately, and you don’t understand what it’s like dealing with all this. When I feel triggered, I just can’t control myself. …
2025-05-28 21:02:39.049 / 3lqb42aajmo2w
… You should know that’s not really me—it’s my past messing with me. I shouldn’t have said what I did, but you have to understand where I’m coming from.”
2025-05-28 21:02:39.050 / 3lqb42aajmp2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in13. Love-Bombing, Instant Intimacy, or the Intimacy Rush
With love-bombing, the manipulator will shower the target with excessive attention, compliments, and affection.
2025-05-28 21:04:04.007 / 3lqb44q2h7h2w
This is usually done inappropriately early in a relationship, often to quickly gain control and trust at the expense of detail or the truth. It can also manifest in an established relationship to regain lost trust or minimize a violation.
2025-05-28 21:04:04.008 / 3lqb44rewlh2w
These eventually lead to devaluation and emotional abuse when it can't be sustained because it's not meant to be sustained.
2025-05-28 21:04:04.009 / 3lqb44rewli2w
"We've only been together for a month, but I feel deep down we're meant to be together forever. It's like I've always known you, and you've always known me. I've never felt so understood by anyone, and I've never loved anyone more than I love you."
2025-05-28 21:04:04.010 / 3lqb44rexkq2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in14. Seduction
Complimenting love-bombing, the manipulator employs charm, compliments, flattery, or overt support to lower other's defenses and secure their trust and loyalty.
2025-05-28 21:05:12.380 / 3lqb46razpq2w
When someone is presented with a remarkably high interest in things regularly overlooked by others, it can be very exciting, even intoxicating. We don't want to believe it isn't true because of the painful disappointment that would incur.
2025-05-28 21:05:12.381 / 3lqb46sj5vi2w
Seduction is characterized by special, and oftentimes unique, appeal. For example, the manipulator may assist the target with something seemingly ignored by others to gain trust and access without raising many suspicions.
2025-05-28 21:05:12.382 / 3lqb46sj6uq2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in15. Poisoning the Well
An unfavorable portrayal of a target is strategically presented to an audience in advance, aiming to discredit or ridicule any of the target's upcoming statements …
2025-05-28 21:06:44.838 / 3lqb4bjgmqa2w
… and avoid any scrutiny that those might invite. Whatever might be judged negatively is a weapon that cuts down the target's reputation, even if it's not true, or worse, founded in irrational bigotry, stereotypes, faulty thinking, stigma, or other unfair prejudices.
2025-05-28 21:06:44.839 / 3lqb4bkpbja2w
Most people aren't aware of their biases, especially if they originate in protection and fear. The presumed justifications nullify their ugly nature.
2025-05-28 21:06:44.840 / 3lqb4bkpcii2w
Layer on the need to not be wrong or immoral so much that they're blind to any consequence of their actions that would illustrate such, and you get an impenetrable but pliable darkness.
2025-05-28 21:06:44.841 / 3lqb4bkpcij2w
"I think the reason they're saying all of that is because they’re looking for attention. They’ve been acting really erratic lately, and honestly, it seems like they might be going through something. It might be better for them to get some help before things spiral out of control."
2025-05-28 21:06:44.842 / 3lqb4bkpcik2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in16. Brandishing Anger
The manipulator intentionally displays intense anger, instilling uncertainty in someone's mind to influence their actions or decisions, often as a response to a decision.
2025-05-28 21:08:20.150 / 3lqb4eedbv22w
Someone else's anger is scary to most people, especially when directed at them. It's an immediate sign of trouble that must be rectified or defended against. The tendency, then, is to prevent the anger from being expressed, especially among individuals who've suffered previously angry abuse.
2025-05-28 21:08:20.151 / 3lqb4effcqs2w
The anger may be unexpected, a total surprise for maximum uncertainty. Or it may be threatened as an intimidating unknown.
2025-05-28 21:08:20.152 / 3lqb4effcqt2w
However, this anger is frequently feigned as a calculated tool to gain leverage or force compliance. It's not actually present, but it's impossible to tell at that moment. It may as well be real.
2025-05-28 21:08:20.153 / 3lqb4effdq32w
Anger brandishment often works not because it's explosive—but because it makes the other person anxious enough to avoid escalation, even if it means sacrificing their needs or voice.
2025-05-28 21:08:20.154 / 3lqb4effdq42w
Teenager: "I don't want to go to that college. I want to apply somewhere else."
Parent (tight smile, hands trembling slightly): "You have no idea what I've sacrificed for you. You're really going to throw away everything? Is that what you're saying?"
2025-05-28 21:08:20.155 / 3lqb4effdq52w
The room is immediately heavy. The teenager is shocked and confused. There is an absence of yelling—but a shouting match hangs pregnant in the air. The parent used implied anger to control the child's choices through fear, not open discussion.
2025-05-28 21:08:20.156 / 3lqb4effdq62w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in17. Pantomimes of Virtue
For the purpose of this article I have avoided the term 'virtue signaling' here because it's become muddied after countless misapplications.
2025-05-28 21:10:05.452 / 3lqb4hiqutw2w
'Virtue Signaling', as might be explained by Ryan Holiday at The Daily Stoic, [is] the public support of something that you deem good and moral to rally others to your cause, is not a tactic of manipulation.
2025-05-28 21:10:05.453 / 3lqb4hjsh2w2w
Virtue Pantomime, however, is different. It isn't simply expressing support for something good or moral. It consists of an outward display of moral righteousness or alignment with socially praised values, but it's a hollow pantomime to counterfeit approval, trust, or influence.
2025-05-28 21:10:05.454 / 3lqb4hkzzo62w
The manipulator often emphasizes their "goodness" not as a genuine expression of belief but as a strategic move to mask ulterior motives, deflect criticism, or pressure others into compliance by implying they lack similar virtues if they disagree, or fail to comply with their demands.
2025-05-28 21:10:05.455 / 3lqb4hkzzo72w
The manipulator not only emphasizes their own moral stance but also implicitly claims authority by suggesting that their way of acting is the correct or necessary course of action.
2025-05-28 21:10:05.456 / 3lqb4hkzzoa2w
They set themselves up as someone who has “learned the hard way,” making their opinion seem more experienced or valid, and subtly pressures others to follow their lead if they want to see change.
2025-05-28 21:10:05.457 / 3lqb4hkzzob2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in18. Diversion
This manipulation tactic has two variations. One involves intentionally diverting the conversation, steering it toward a different topic to center it as the focal point, especially during an argument.
2025-05-28 21:11:32.674 / 3lqb4k3wnmb2w
Whataboutism is a classic example:
"Why are we even talking about my mistake? What about all the times you've messed up?"
2025-05-28 21:11:32.675 / 3lqb4k555zr2w
The other involves redirecting the target's, or the larger situation's observers', attention away from anything that poses a danger to the manipulator. Prime substitutional candidates include, but not exclusively, a common enemy, gripe, cause, …
2025-05-28 21:11:32.676 / 3lqb4k555zs2w
… or a more egregious offense by someone else, even one outside of the problem. Distraction, any distraction, is the goal so the manipulator can keep others from examining things too closely or inferring inconvenient conclusions.
2025-05-28 21:11:32.677 / 3lqb4k556z22w
"Forget gas prices! your kids are being taught they can change genders before they can drive a car!"
2025-05-28 21:11:32.678 / 3lqb4k556z32w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in19. Encouraging Self-Doubt
People are generally unsure of themselves in complex situations or unfamiliar environments. Add social anxiety or the goal of doing something different, and one has a constant fear …
2025-05-28 21:13:01.438 / 3lqb4mqlj7d2w
that they'll be seen as out of place, rejected, or even do something inappropriate.
2025-05-28 21:13:01.439 / 3lqb4mroyx32w
The manipulator will endeavor to take advantage of any opportunity or invent opportunities to plant these seeds of doubt and insecurity in someone else's mind. The goal is to make them question their own discernment or judgment without any intervention, doing the manipulator's work for them.
2025-05-28 21:13:01.440 / 3lqb4mroyx42w
This occurs frequently, both personally and on many dimensional surfaces of greater society, and each is as treacherous as the manipulator's aims.
2025-05-28 21:13:01.441 / 3lqb4mrozwe2w
"You’re so confident right now, but I just can’t help but wonder—are you really thinking clearly? It’s almost like when you're so certain, you tend to lose track of what’s important. You’ve done that before, right? Sometimes I think your mind doesn’t allow you to see things the way others do.”
2025-05-28 21:13:01.442 / 3lqb4mrozwf2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in20. Feigning Innocence
This tactic is aimed at the manipulator but affects the target. Manipulators will actively downplay any harm caused through various means, as this list outlines.
2025-05-28 21:14:36.253 / 3lqb4pkz2xf2w
A popular one is a feigning of innocence, where they contend that everything was unintentional or a result of ignorance, emphasized with pretenses of surprise or, if unbelievable, indignation.
2025-05-28 21:14:36.254 / 3lqb4pm2szv2w
This tactic causes the victim to question their conclusions and, at times, their sanity by adding subtle hints to undermine the target's judgment. It also offers outsiders reasonable motivations to discount the target's grievance.
2025-05-28 21:14:36.255 / 3lqb4pm2szw2w
How can you hold someone accountable for something they didn't mean or know about?
2025-05-28 21:14:36.256 / 3lqb4pm2tz62w
"Wait, what? You think I meant to hurt you? That’s ridiculous! I didn’t even realize it was affecting you like that. I would never do something like that on purpose! I didn’t know I was causing any harm. I’m really surprised you’d think I was capable of something like that."
2025-05-28 21:14:36.257 / 3lqb4pm2tz72w
Victims of manipulators may show signs of this strategy. The difference between these and the manipulator's lies relies on factual observations of ignorance. The manipulator may keep the target in the dark, only to reveal something they would've wanted to know later.
2025-05-28 21:14:36.258 / 3lqb4pm2tza2w
Unfortunately, most likely at the hands of the manipulator, it was always apparent to everyone else. This makes the victim's claims of ignorance pale compared to the manipulator's stated 'good intentions.'
2025-05-28 21:14:36.259 / 3lqb4pm2tzb2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in21. Projection
The manipulator shifts their uncomfortable thoughts or actions onto another to ease their own discomfort. The exceedingly insecure will do this pathologically because they cannot confront the shame they might feel.
2025-05-28 21:15:40.514 / 3lqb4ric5tr2w
At first, the mechanics of projection can seem nonsensical, but there is an emotive logic. Emotional projection uses the target as a neutral psychological canvas to work through issues without suffering the negative consequences of ownership. Instead, they are inflicted upon the disposable canvas.
2025-05-28 21:15:40.515 / 3lqb4rjlk2r2w
Projection can be fairly compelling, making it highly chaotic, causing confusion, and forcing the target to question their recollection of events. An example of projection can involve one partner blaming the other for their own flaws, such as disorganization or messiness.
2025-05-28 21:15:40.516 / 3lqb4rjlk2s2w
Projecting insecurities can also manifest as accusing a partner of flirting with others. The person may feel guilty for being attracted to someone else, thus turning to emotional projection to protect their psyche while still attempting to work through the issue internally.
2025-05-28 21:15:40.517 / 3lqb4rjll222w
This is a doomed endeavor; unfortunately, even when attempted in good faith, it never works. The original issues remain unresolved because the consequences weren't experienced, and the manipulator repeats the process, at best unaware of its maladaptiveness.
2025-05-28 21:15:40.518 / 3lqb4rjll232w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in22. Invalidation
Validation can be tricky and complicated to pin down as it looks different to different people, relationships, and circumstances. However, its core is simple.
2025-05-28 21:18:01.778 / 3lqb4voz6xt2w
Validation and invalidation rest on a common perception of implicit proto-approval, not agreeance, predicated on an external recognition of existence. It's not an endorsement of something but an acknowledgment that something 'can' or does exist despite no one 'allowing' things to exist.
2025-05-28 21:18:01.779 / 3lqb4vq7y6l2w
It's psychological and a purely social construct. It's most observable in cultural power dynamics over what is considered 'normal' and thus appropriate.
2025-05-28 21:18:01.780 / 3lqb4vq7y6m2w
Validation is recognizing that someone has thoughts and feelings to be considered, while invalidation dismisses them as unworthy of consideration. A sign of validation is when someone feels heard, and a sign of invalidation is when someone feels ignored or like they don't exist.
2025-05-28 21:18:01.781 / 3lqb4vq7z5u2w
Invalidation isn't always intentional, but manipulative invalidation is. It consists of denying or discounting a person's concerns, many times through erosion of justification and a war of attrition.
2025-05-28 21:18:01.782 / 3lqb4vq7z5v2w
Implications that the target is being 'too sensitive,' acting 'crazy,' and being 'unreasonable' are typical go-tos. There is a constant downplaying of the person's emotional importance compared to everyone else, even if it remains unsaid and done through sarcasm.
2025-05-28 21:18:01.783 / 3lqb4vq7z5w2w
These are the manipulator's favorite insults because they plant insecurities built to seek revalidation, but it is a reassurance only the manipulator's approval seems to deliver.
2025-05-28 21:18:01.784 / 3lqb4vq7z5x2w
"You're making a mountain out of a molehill. It’s really not worth all this drama. I don’t know why you’re so focused on it when everyone else has already moved on."
2025-05-28 21:18:01.785 / 3lqb4vqa2572w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in23. Double Standards
The manipulator will apply different rules or expectations to others or themselves in similar situations.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.314 / 3lqb536yrvx2w
Ironically, this is often done to undermine someone's argument, position, or credibility by highlighting perceived inconsistencies in their behavior or standards despite permitting the same thing themselves.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.315 / 3lqb53abho72w
It fits snugly within the projection and punishment framework regarding their insecurities when they do the same things. This often makes it subconsciously relatable to their supporters.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.316 / 3lqb53abinh2w
Confronting double standards can be exceptionally challenging. It's near-impossible for an objective standard of fairness to cut through group alliances.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.317 / 3lqb53abini2w
This is because they immediately create a power imbalance, as the accuser has already committed the same offense. And yet, it doesn't seem to matter. But it should matter!
2025-05-28 21:21:06.318 / 3lqb53abinj2w
A sense of injustice is aroused in the target, who may respond indignantly, or inversely, they may resentfully rise to the one-sided standard.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.319 / 3lqb53abink2w
Woefully, either path tends to weaken the target's perceived position within the conflict because it sows doubt and ridicule from anyone who's already judged the target through the eyes of the manipulator.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.320 / 3lqb53abjms2w
The manipulator's supporter, possibly remembering what the manipulator has done, is convinced by the target's reaction to believe the manipulator possesses greater wisdom or power, having been justified or remaining unchallenged.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.321 / 3lqb53abjmt2w
This confirmation bias reinforces the manipulator's superiority over the maligned target's scrambling.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.322 / 3lqb53abjmu2w
A manager constantly criticizes an employee for taking too long on a project, while the manager themselves has a habit of missing deadlines or procrastinating on critical tasks.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.323 / 3lqb53abkm42w
When the employee tries to address this inconsistency, the manager accuses them of being "too sensitive" and "not understanding the pressure they’re under," even though they hold the employee to a stricter standard than themselves.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.324 / 3lqb53abkm52w
A friend consistently bails out of group plans, leaving others to adjust at the last minute. However, when another friend does the same thing on one occasion, they’re publicly scolded for being unreliable and "selfish," despite the manipulator regularly doing the same thing without consequence.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.325 / 3lqb53abkm62w
The manipulator downplays their own behavior, creating a perception that only the other person is in the wrong.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.326 / 3lqb53abkm72w
A parent criticizes their child for skipping an extracurricular activity, even though the parent often skips social or family events for personal reasons.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.327 / 3lqb53abkma2w
The parent accuses the child of being disrespectful and irresponsible, while their own similar behavior is overlooked or justified as "different" due to a number of excuses.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.328 / 3lqb53abkmb2w
A partner frequently criticizes their significant other for not being emotionally open or for needing space, while they themselves regularly shut down emotionally or distance themselves when facing stress.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.329 / 3lqb53abkmc2w
When the partner confronts them about it, the manipulator insists that the other person is "too needy" or "unreasonable" for expecting the same openness from them.
2025-05-28 21:21:06.330 / 3lqb53abkmd2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in24. Shifting Context
This one's a doozy. It's complicated, nuanced, and hard to fully portray faithfully due to its overwhelming and disorganized nature. The manipulator creates an ever-shifting contextual chaos …
2025-05-28 21:23:14.278 / 3lqb56yzwrd2w
to make the situation so fluid and voluble that no correct or beneficial action is available to the target.
2025-05-28 21:23:14.279 / 3lqb5725od32w
This is generally intended to wear down the target's defenses and make them more prone to remain quiet and compliant because they cannot predict what context will come next.
2025-05-28 21:23:14.280 / 3lqb5725od42w
Partner A: "I feel like you've been really distant lately. We barely spend time together."
Partner B: "Oh, so now you're saying I'm a terrible partner? What about all the times I've been there for you?"
2025-05-28 21:23:14.281 / 3lqb5725od52w
Partner A: "I'm not saying that; I'm just trying to talk about how I feel."
Partner B: "You always do this. Every time I have a stressful week and have to be elsewhere, you make it all about you instead of supporting me. I'm actually about ready to fall apart because of this."
2025-05-28 21:23:14.282 / 3lqb5725pcf2w
In this exchange, Partner B shifts the context of the conversation from Partner A's genuine unease about an impending emotional distance to an artificial crisis concerning Partner A's supposed lack of support.
2025-05-28 21:23:14.283 / 3lqb5725pcg2w
By constantly moving the focus, Partner A is put on the defensive and never gets to address their original concern.
2025-05-28 21:23:14.284 / 3lqb5725pch2w
Sometimes, this seemingly topsy-turvy atmosphere is unintentional. The suspected manipulator may be surrounded by a cloud of confusion because they are unaware of subconscious mechanisms at work and act out of habit, or worse, out of pure unmitigated instability and uncontrollably erratic behaviors.
2025-05-28 21:23:14.285 / 3lqb5725pci2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in25. Feigning Confusion
This is another façade that manipulators will quickly adopt, even nonsensically. Who can prove it's not accurate? They'll pretend to be confused or unaware of what the victim is talking about.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.126 / 3lqb5domkni2w
This tactic aims to confuse the victim, causing them to question the accuracy of their own perceptions or over-explain out of obligation or frustration.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.127 / 3lqb5dprs2i2w
It also influences others observing the exchange, if present, to doubt the victim's credibility and motivations. Additionally, it provides immediate cover for the manipulator when the tides start to turn against them.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.128 / 3lqb5dprs2j2w
They were confused and required understanding and pity, not explanation or beratement.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.129 / 3lqb5dprs2k2w
But how can one detect fraudulent confusion? Its self-evidence directly correlates to its unbelievability or convenience. The more outrageous or convenient the inability to understand, the more likely it is feigned.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.130 / 3lqb5dprszs2w
If the target uses the same terms as the manipulator in the same context, and yet their question remains incomprehensible, at what point can it be concluded that the manipulator simply can't read? It's just too unbelievable.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.131 / 3lqb5dprszt2w
Suppose the manipulator employed adequate comprehension until a contradiction painted them into a corner. Suddenly, they don't know how to do anything because everything is overwhelming and confusing. In that case, it's a safe bet it's a performance.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.132 / 3lqb5dprszu2w
Conversely, if they can't understand you, but when you point out you used the exact words they did, what else could it mean, they suddenly have an appropriate answer. You clearly weren't the source of confusion.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.133 / 3lqb5dprszv2w
"Wait, what? I honestly don't know what you're going on about. I don't know how that relates to anything I have said."
2025-05-28 21:25:51.134 / 3lqb5dprszw2w
A subset of this tactic is pretending to be confused about someone’s clearly-stated motivation, actions or statements, upon which the manipulator is often a quick to comment.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.135 / 3lqb5dprszx2w
This allows the manipulator the ability to impose their own context upon the situation as a subtle strawman argument, recontextualizing the target’s original intent into something that is suitable for the manipulator’s messaging.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.136 / 3lqb5dprszy2w
A person confronts someone for consistently disregarding their grievances. The manipulator focuses on a comparison the person made between their actions and a character from a TV show they both watch.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.137 / 3lqb5dprtza2w
The manipulator ignores the actual criticism and focuses on the aspect that the comparison had been made to a TV show they both like.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.138 / 3lqb5dprtzb2w
They reframe the argument as hinging on the idea that the comparison is mocking their enjoyment of the show, and then dismiss the situation as invalid because it does not add up because the other person also also enjoys the show.
2025-05-28 21:25:51.139 / 3lqb5dprtzc2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in26. Leveraging Obligations
The manipulator disguises the pressure to act to their needs as an expression of care or duty to fulfill, often alluding to some service or favor rendered in the past, …
2025-05-28 21:27:42.735 / 3lqb5gz2kts2w
… regardless of their current bad behavior.
This is obvious in more intimate relationships, eventually appearing as unspoken threats of endless rehash if the partner doesn't comply. It's also clear when there is a power imbalance and the alleged benefactor controls your, or the endeavor's, future.
2025-05-28 21:27:42.736 / 3lqb5h2cozk2w
"I raised you, put food on the table, and now you can't even visit me once a week?"
2025-05-28 21:27:42.737 / 3lqb5h2cozl2w
But it's harder to spot in other, less binding relationships. It's especially tough when the obligation relates to an abstraction, such as an unspoken and thus undefined social contract, rather than a particular person.
2025-05-28 21:27:42.738 / 3lqb5h2cpyt2w
This variation is commonly in the inverse, which centers the idea that the target owes everyone the benefit of everything, including doubt, even if none of it is afforded to the target.
2025-05-28 21:27:42.739 / 3lqb5h2cpyu2w
In these cases, the target is usually told that they must always be "the better person," granting a perverse grace to their abusers.
2025-05-28 21:27:42.740 / 3lqb5h2cpyv2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in27. Intentional Vagueness
Vagueness is the most insidious strategy employed by manipulators because it allows them to hide behind many acceptable defenses.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.615 / 3lqb5lwcdh52w
People are often vague for good reasons: privacy, protection, politeness (particularly around embarrassing topics), and more sophisticated purposes like informing others of important information without further instigating unnecessary attention or conflict.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.616 / 3lqb5lxqb6f2w
The takeaway is that vagueness doesn't directly translate to manipulation, and that's a problem when dealing with manipulators who have an audience.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.617 / 3lqb5lxqb6g2w
Vagueness serves its purpose as a manipulation tactic by intentionally keeping information unclear and ambiguous.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.618 / 3lqb5lxqb6h2w
This enables the manipulator to control the narrative, evade accountability, and craft statements that could apply to multiple individuals, particularly if they are known for volatile interactions.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.619 / 3lqb5lxqb6i2w
When confronted, they can deny targeting anyone specifically, maintaining control over the situation and reinforcing their power, while delivering their message in such a way that an inner group can easily identify the individuals singled out—even if it is difficult to do so from the outside.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.620 / 3lqb5lxqb6j2w
This is most apparent when targets repeatedly face this situation:
If they highlight what the manipulator says as relating to them, they are chastised for their self-importance and are always wrong.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.621 / 3lqb5lxqc5r2w
But if they abstain, others less confident in interpreting the situation inquire if what the manipulator said is about the target. The more often this happens, the more obvious the manipulation. A consistent run over a decade could indicate a profound pathology.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.622 / 3lqb5lxqc5s2w
Vagueness can also repackage things under a broader and more persuasive umbrella. A contentious text chat becomes screaming at someone. A sarcastic remark becomes an indication of zero empathy. A serious violation becomes a misunderstanding and is thus excusable.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.623 / 3lqb5lxqc5t2w
A fake Facebook example using the most generic of vague-post formats. It's literally everywhere.
2025-05-28 21:30:27.624 / 3lqb5lxqhzd2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in28. Gaslighting
The term gaslighting, or being gaslit, I guess, has become a favorite and popular refrain among many. However, as with all terms appropriated for a trend, …
2025-05-28 21:33:05.544 / 3lqb5qmvvzd2w
… broadening its scope to situations where it doesn't apply has frustrated those who wish to use it appropriately. When gaslighting's scope is too broad, it becomes a signifier for a defensive emotion detached from its original meaning despite, unfortunately, not shedding that meaning when employed.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.545 / 3lqb5qobqed2w
Gaslighting is an opaque denial of reality. It attempts to undermine the target's sanity by insisting that events that happened never happened or that events that never happened did.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.546 / 3lqb5qobqee2w
It's executed to avoid the consequences of what did happen or to intentionally break down the confidence of another in their own perceptions and reasoning.
They are to be replaced by the manipulator's.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.547 / 3lqb5qobrdm2w
"I never called you that. You must be remembering wrong."
"That book wasn't there last night. You just aren't very observant."
2025-05-28 21:33:05.548 / 3lqb5qobrdn2w
"You're imagining things. Why would anyone ever do that to you? I think you're remembering it the way you want to remember it. That’s not how it happened at all, and deep down, you know that."
2025-05-28 21:33:05.549 / 3lqb5qobrdo2w
However, suppose someone states a perspective that puts you on the defensive, even if it's simply a different interpretation of the objective facts. In that case, it's convenient and attractively self-serving to accuse them of gaslighting, even if they are being accurate.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.550 / 3lqb5qobrdp2w
In reality, the opposition isn't "validating," or essentially agreeing wholeheartedly, with everything you think or feel. Observers, especially moral supporters, struggle to distinguish this when they aren't privy to the original context.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.551 / 3lqb5qobscx2w
When everyone's only concerned with your perspective, it stands to reason the opposition must be manipulating the past or the situation, so gaslighting fits the bill.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.552 / 3lqb5qobtc72w
Unfortunately, gaslighting carries the connotative weight of abuse and evokes memories of malicious intent in many, bypassing necessary critical observation.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.553 / 3lqb5qobtca2w
In today's climate of convenient therapy terms that mean what you need them to mean, as put out by your favorite TikTok therapist, it's no wonder this term and concept is responsible for some of the most complex and sophisticated DARVO deployments.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.554 / 3lqb5qobtcb2w
It's easily packaged into one malleable word, an accusation that doesn't require explanation. It instantly creates an unexamined and frequently unnecessary topology of conflict that balloons into lengthy and complex theses without anyone realizing that's what's happening.
2025-05-28 21:33:05.555 / 3lqb5qobubj2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in29. Intimidation
Intimidation is the intentional cultivation of fear surrounding the manipulator through bravado, unsaid but understood ramifications of their responses, and plain threats.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.646 / 3lqb5v6waob2w
This strategy is exceptionally straightforward, and almost everyone can recognize it even when they don't immediately realize it's happening. And yet, it's also one of the most complex. What is the difference between intimidation and intimidating?
2025-05-28 21:35:38.647 / 3lqb5v7yv2z2w
Unfair false flags occur if we drop context. Suppose someone can easily overwhelm just because they feel like it. In that case, it follows that worse will occur when they are motivated. This is intimidating, but that impression may exist naturally, not intentionally.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.648 / 3lqb5v7yv322w
Otherwise, we could consider the consequences of attacking a Navy Seal as opposed to a child, and end up identifying the Seal's strength as abuse by virtue of existing.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.649 / 3lqb5v7yv332w
Intimidation is intentional, and because of that, it takes the form of threats. It's a purposeful but surreptitious flex to demonstrate concealed strength that would go unchallenged.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.650 / 3lqb5v7yv342w
It's a nod that something terrible will happen if the manipulator doesn't get his way. It's a veiled threat, like "it's a shame if something happens to your shiny new car," or a more direct one, "… or else I'll be forced to eliminate the problem."
2025-05-28 21:35:38.651 / 3lqb5v7yw2e2w
They can be general, "I'm capable of incarcerating someone just because I don't like them," or specific, "I look forward to ruining your life." They can even be hinting insinuations, reinforced by it being a reaction or attached to a demand.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.652 / 3lqb5v7yw2f2w
All threats are usually exaggerated, but they never appear as such because of the unknown possibilities.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.653 / 3lqb5v7yw2g2w
Intimidation is qualified by a threat of action whose sole purpose is to silence, oppress, and force others to do what the manipulator wants at the point of a metaphorical or literal gun. It cannot be nullified by stating that a threat of action isn't a threat.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.654 / 3lqb5v7yw2h2w
Consenting under duress isn't consent, but violation, and intimidation is instrumental in the initiation of violence requiring submission.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.655 / 3lqb5v7yw2i2w
Even in opposition, a declaration of future action isn't automatically a threat. Likewise, strength without danger isn't intimidation; it's just intimidating and thus requires no special supervision.
2025-05-28 21:35:38.656 / 3lqb5v7ywzq2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.in30. Triangulation or Pot Stirring
Manipulators position themselves at the center of this dramatic game, playing two or more people, or sides, against each other by spreading lies, half-truths, or gossip.
2025-05-28 21:37:18.244 / 3lqb5y5vqdy2w
This tactic leads to division and conflict between the parties being manipulated, often resulting in fighting and discord that the manipulator can exploit for personal gain or power.
2025-05-28 21:37:18.245 / 3lqb5y6xt6a2w
A classic example is the controlling partner telling their significant other "Your best friend doesn't really like me and thinks I'm bad for you." They subsequently tell the best friend: "My partner said they're realizing you're a toxic influence."
2025-05-28 21:37:18.246 / 3lqb5y6xt6b2w
This isolates the partner from their support system while keeping control over the narrative.
2025-05-28 21:37:18.247 / 3lqb5y6xt6c2w
Triangulation may seem innocuous, but it can be devastating. Minor misunderstandings or lack of communication can result in decades-long estrangements over nothing, leaving the parties in tatters with regret.
2025-05-28 21:37:18.248 / 3lqb5y6xt6d2w
Triangulation always risks getting out of hand. On every front, in the heart of the situation or from the outside, seemingly insignificant pot stirring can materialize into a highly charged and incendiary controversy constantly on the verge of erupting into scandal.
2025-05-28 21:37:18.249 / 3lqb5y6xu5l2w
But this would be considered a success!
2025-05-28 21:37:18.250 / 3lqb5y6xu5m2w
The manipulator wishes for this to be the default irrevocable state. It will never fully recover; the damage is done, and the truth is replaced. Who will double-check or reify any of their beliefs when there isn't any benefit to doing so, only trouble?
2025-05-28 21:37:18.251 / 3lqb5y6xu5n2w
Why follow up on terrible claims from horrible haters when they only aim to destroy their now mythic and rallied-around foe, the great manipulator?
2025-05-28 21:37:18.252 / 3lqb5y6xu5o2w
In online spaces, manipulators also have a tendency to employ alternate identities, impersonate others or to post under different usernames in order to create the illusion of, or increase the impression of, an escalation in two parts of a conflict.
2025-05-28 21:37:18.253 / 3lqb5y6xu5p2w
On Manipulation
By @merrystarchild.bsky.social and @asher.wolfste.inNot An Exhaustive List
This is by no means an exhaustive list, but it is a comprehensive listing of the most common manipulation tactics. It is important to understand in what context a claim to manipulative behavior is made.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.263 / 3lqb65frewp2w
Unfortunately, like gaslighting and narcissist, accusations of manipulation have recently gained an increased social momentum that makes them attractive.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.264 / 3lqb65gw7nh2w
Countless talking heads on unvetted platforms like YouTube or TikTok are constantly handing out listicle-like soundbites illustrating simple tricks to defend your peace of mind against the black arts.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.265 / 3lqb65gwamp2w
Those with personality disorders or other conditions resulting in even a semblance of anti-social behavior are branded malignant villainous narcissists who wish to use and abuse you in a sick covert game of sexual gratification.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.266 / 3lqb65gwamq2w
It's a Satanic panic, sometimes even involving frightening imagery and hellish moral battles against an unknown nebulous cabal. In the reverse, they invoke power beyond dreams of avarice, teasing us with rebelliously sexy secrets of the 'masters in dark psychology.'
2025-05-28 21:40:14.267 / 3lqb65gwamr2w
In that terminally online culture that seeps into our everyday consciousness now, who wants to be seen as manipulative? And who would throw around those accusations knowing their weight?
2025-05-28 21:40:14.268 / 3lqb65gwams2w
However, when a situation or a dialogue meets multiples of these criteria remarkably efficiently, especially when they are one-sided, it's more reasonable to conclude …
2025-05-28 21:40:14.269 / 3lqb65gwbm22w
… that the term is an honest observation rather than an unfounded and biased accusation meant to hurt by Occam's Razor alone. Sometimes, the observation requires expression.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.270 / 3lqb65gwbm32w
Claims of manipulation are best supported by the standards of discourse, in which a claim is made and then supported by backing arguments of why the claim was made, pointing to concrete actions taken and words spoken.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.271 / 3lqb65gwbm42w
But why make the observation? Telling someone they are manipulative isn't foolish or unnecessary, even if the individual is highly manipulative. It tells the manipulator that you are aware of what they are doing and indicates this awareness to others.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.272 / 3lqb65gwbm52w
This helpfully informs others, like a warning call, that they should be wary. It creates a concrete situation that provides an appropriate motivation for the guilty to stop what they're doing. Whether they do this is another matter.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.273 / 3lqb65gwbm62w
As mentioned above, we are all capable of manipulation and of being manipulated at times—
2025-05-28 21:40:14.274 / 3lqb65gwbm72w
the important question is whether a person's default strategies for conflict resolution and interpersonal dynamics center around manipulation, at which point there is a concrete case for considering them manipulative.
2025-05-28 21:40:14.275 / 3lqb65gwbma2w
The list:
2025-05-28 21:48:13.120 / 3lqb6logxpi2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.121 / 3lqb6lokupi2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.122 / 3lqb6lokupj2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.123 / 3lqb6lokvor2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.124 / 3lqb6lokwnz2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.125 / 3lqb6lokwo22w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.126 / 3lqb6lokwo32w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.127 / 3lqb6lokxnd2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.128 / 3lqb6lokxne2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.129 / 3lqb6lokxnf2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.130 / 3lqb6lokymn2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.131 / 3lqb6lokymo2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.132 / 3lqb6lokymp2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.133 / 3lqb6lokzlx2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.134 / 3lqb6lokzly2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.135 / 3lqb6lokzlz2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.136 / 3lqb6lokzm22w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.137 / 3lqb6lol2lc2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.138 / 3lqb6lol2ld2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.139 / 3lqb6lol2le2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.140 / 3lqb6lol3km2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.141 / 3lqb6lol3kn2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.142 / 3lqb6lol3ko2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.143 / 3lqb6lol3kp2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.144 / 3lqb6lol3kq2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.145 / 3lqb6lol4jy2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.146 / 3lqb6lol4jz2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.147 / 3lqb6lol4k22w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.148 / 3lqb6lol4k32w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.149 / 3lqb6lol4k42w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.150 / 3lqb6lol4k52w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.151 / 3lqb6lol4k62w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.152 / 3lqb6lol4k72w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.153 / 3lqb6lol5jh2w
bsky.app/profile/ashe…
2025-05-28 21:48:13.154 / 3lqb6lol6ip2w
ATProto root record: 3lq7gxnv75f2m